doingthesums

Switching

Debt consolidation: cheaper, or just longer?

Rolling several debts into one almost always lowers what you pay each month. Whether it lowers what you pay in total is a different question, and it depends entirely on the term.

What you owe now

Put in what you actually pay each month, not the minimum shown on the statement — see the note on minimums.

The one loan

%
yrs
$

Application and establishment fees, added to the loan.

 As it isOne loan

Your debts average — across the balances owing. That is the rate the one loan has to beat.

Each debt on its own

DebtRatePaid offInterest

If you are struggling to keep up, this is the wrong page

A consolidation loan is for someone who can afford their debts and wants them cheaper. If you are missing payments or borrowing to make them, free financial counselling will do more for you than any loan, and it is genuinely free and independent.

National Debt Helpline — 1800 007 007, or ndh.org.au. We are not paid anything for sending you there, which is rather the point.

Why one loan at a lower rate can cost you more

Every debt above gets a lower rate, and the total still goes up. That is not a trick in the arithmetic — it is the term. A credit card balance you would have cleared in three years, stretched over seven, accrues interest for four extra years, and four years of a lower rate on a balance that is still there beats one year of a higher rate on a balance that is gone.

The lower monthly repayment is the product being sold. The longer term is the price, and it is not usually on the label. The number worth watching on this page is not the repayment — it is total interest, in the row second from the bottom.

The version that does work

Consolidate to a lower rate, then keep paying what you pay now. The rate cut stops buying you a smaller repayment and starts buying you an earlier finish, which is the thing you actually wanted. The callout above works out what that is worth on your figures.

The catch is behavioural rather than mathematical: the repayment on the new loan will be lower, so paying more than it requires is a decision you have to keep making. Setting the direct debit to the old total on day one is how people make it stick.

How this is worked out

  • Each debt is amortised at its own rate against the repayment you entered, then the interest is added up.
  • Repayments are held flat. A real credit card minimum is a percentage of the balance, so it falls as the balance falls and the card takes decades. Holding it flat makes your current position look better than a true minimum-payment case — which is the safe direction to be wrong in, on a page that is paid when you switch.
  • Set-up fees are added to the new loan, which is how a consolidation is normally written.
  • The new loan is unsecured-style: one balance, one rate, one term, no redraw.
  • Not included: balance-transfer offers, interest-free periods, early repayment or discharge fees on your existing debts, and anything secured against your home.

Rolling debt into your mortgage is a different calculation

It is the cheapest rate available to most people and the longest term available to anyone. A $15,000 card balance at 6% over 25 remaining years costs more in interest than at 20% over three — and it is now secured against your house. If that is what you are considering, the offset and extra repayments calculator is the better tool: model it as a bigger balance and see the finish date move.