doingthesums

Cars

Refinance a car loan

A car loan refinance is sold on the repayment, and the repayment can be made to fall two ways: a better rate, or a longer loan. Only one of them saves you money. This works out which one you are being offered.

The loan you have

$

What your lender says it would take to settle the loan today, not the original amount.

%
mo
$

Also called a residual. Leave it at zero if the loan pays off in full.

The loan you are offered

%
mo
$
$

Early termination or break fee on the old loan, plus establishment fees on the new one. Often $400–$1,200 all up.

 StayingSwitching

What is left to pay

Staying Switching

Why the repayment is the wrong number to look at

Take $25,000 owing at 11.5% with four years to run. Refinance it to 7.5% — four whole percentage points cheaper — but over seven years instead of four. The repayment falls from $652 a month to $383, which looks like an unambiguous win, and you end up about $1,300 worse off.

Nothing dishonest has happened. The rate genuinely fell. It is just that three extra years of interest on a balance that is still there costs more than four points saves. The repayment went down because the loan got longer, and a longer loan is a bigger loan.

So this page reports total money out of pocket as the headline, and the repayment as a supporting row. If the term changes, it says so in a warning you cannot miss.

Balloons do the same thing, more quietly

A balloon or residual is a chunk of the loan parked at the end. It lowers every repayment before it, and it is still owed. Raising the balloon on a refinance is the fastest way to make a repayment look better without making the loan cheaper. On $25,000 at 9% over four years, adding an $8,000 balloon drops the repayment from $622 a month to $483 — and costs you $1,324 more, at exactly the same rate.

When the balloon falls due you pay it, refinance it, or sell the car. Only the first of those is finished.

How this is worked out

  • Both loans are amortised period by period on the payout figure, not the original loan amount.
  • Total cost is every dollar that leaves your account — repayments, the balloon when it falls due, and the switching fees. That is the only comparison that survives the terms being different lengths.
  • Break-even is found by following both running totals until the new one goes below the old one. Dividing the fee by the monthly saving — which is what most calculators do — reports a break-even in month two for the $1,300 loss above.
  • Switching fees are treated as paid up front, not rolled into the new loan. Rolling them in makes the repayment lower and the total higher.
  • Not included: comprehensive insurance, warranties or add-ons sold with the refinance, GAP cover, and anything secured against something other than the car.
  • Rates are assumed fixed for the term, which for car finance is usually true.

Two things worth doing before you refinance

  • Ask your current lender for the payout figure in writing. It includes any early termination fee, and on some loans that fee is large enough to end the conversation.
  • Check whether the car is worth more than the loan. If it is not, no lender will refinance the whole balance, and the gap is the real problem rather than the rate.