What a broker is
A bank can only offer you a bank’s loans. A mortgage broker has accreditation with a panel of lenders — typically twenty to forty, including the big four, the smaller banks, credit unions and lenders that have no branches at all — and can put your application to any of them.
They do the comparing, fill in the application, deal with the lender’s questions, and chase it through to settlement. In Australia they are licensed under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act and, since 2021, they have a best interests duty: a legal obligation to act in your interests, not the lender’s. A bank’s own lender has no such duty to you.
Roughly three in four new home loans in Australia are now written through a broker rather than directly with a lender.
Who pays them
The lender does. When your loan settles, the lender pays the broker a commission. It comes in two parts:
Those are the typical ranges, not a quote. They vary by lender and by the broker’s own arrangements, and a broker has to tell you what they’ll be paid before you apply.
There is a catch worth knowing: if you repay or refinance the loan within the first two years, the lender usually claws the upfront commission back from the broker. That is why some brokers are lukewarm about a refinance they arranged eighteen months ago.
Does it cost you more?
This is the single most common misunderstanding about brokers, and it is reasonable to be suspicious — someone is getting paid, so surely it is coming from you. It generally isn’t. Lenders pay commission because a broker brings them a customer they would otherwise have had to find and process themselves, which is cheaper than a branch network. The rate you are offered through a broker is the same one that lender would offer you directly, and brokers often negotiate a discount off it.
Some brokers do charge a fee. It’s uncommon for a straightforward home loan and more likely for complicated cases — self-employed income, commercial lending, a difficult credit history. If there is a fee, it must be disclosed in writing before you commit to anything. Ask in the first five minutes.
Where the conflict actually is
Not in the rate you pay, but in which lender gets recommended. Commission rates differ between lenders, so a broker has a financial reason to prefer some over others. The best interests duty exists precisely because of that, and it has teeth — but it is still worth asking directly.
Two questions settle most of it:
- “How many lenders are on your panel, and how many did you actually compare?” A shortlist of three from a panel of thirty is normal. A shortlist of one is a conversation worth having.
- “Do you get paid more by the lender you’re recommending than by the others you looked at?” They have to answer honestly, and the answer is usually no — but asking changes the conversation.
There’s also a simpler conflict that nobody mentions: a broker is paid when a loan settles, so they are never paid for telling you to stay where you are. Which is why the break-even sum is worth doing yourself first.
Broker, or straight to the bank?
A broker tends to win when
- You’re a first home buyer and don’t know what you can borrow.
- Your income is awkward — self-employed, contract, bonus-heavy, overseas.
- You have a small deposit and need a lender who’ll take it.
- You’ve been knocked back somewhere and don’t know why.
- You don’t have the time or appetite to ring six lenders yourself.
Going direct tends to win when
- You just want your existing lender to lower your rate — a broker can’t help with that and isn’t paid to.
- You already know exactly which product you want.
- Your bank has a loyalty or package deal that isn’t on broker channels.
- The lender you want doesn’t deal through brokers at all — a few don’t.
The two aren’t exclusive. Plenty of people ring their own bank first, get a number, and then hand that number to a broker to beat.
Start with the free phone call Asking your current lender to match what they advertise to new customers costs nothing and often gets most of the gain. How that conversation goes →What actually happens
- 01A first conversation, usually half an hour, in person or over the phone. What you earn, what you owe, what you’re trying to buy.
- 02They give you a figure and a shortlist of lenders, with the rate, the fees and the features side by side. Ask for it in writing.
- 03Documents. Payslips, bank statements, ID, tax returns if you’re self-employed. This is the slow part and it is mostly on you.
- 04They submit the application to the lender you chose and handle the back-and-forth. Pre-approval typically takes a few days to a couple of weeks.
- 05Valuation and formal approval, then settlement. The broker chases it; you sign things.
- 06They get paid, by the lender, after it settles. Not before, and not by you.
What to ask them
- How many lenders are on your panel, and which did you compare for me?
- What will you be paid on this loan, upfront and trail?
- Do you charge me a fee, in any circumstances?
- Is the lender you’re recommending paying you more than the others?
- What’s the comparison rate, and what fees are in it?
- Who is your credit licence with, and what’s your credit representative number?
That last one lets you check them on ASIC’s professional registers. It takes a minute and almost nobody does it.
Quick answers
Do I pay a mortgage broker?
Usually not. The lender pays them a commission when your loan settles, and it comes out of the lender’s margin rather than being added to your rate. A minority of brokers charge a fee for complex cases, and they must tell you in writing before you commit.
Does using a broker mean a worse rate?
No. You’re offered the same rates the lender would give you directly, and brokers frequently negotiate a discount. What you lose is access to the handful of lenders who don’t use broker channels at all.
Is a broker’s commission the same as a kickback?
It’s a disclosed commission, not a secret one. Brokers have to tell you what they’ll be paid, and since 2021 they’ve had a legal best interests duty to you. The thing to actually watch is whether the lender being recommended pays more than the ones that weren’t — so ask.
Can a broker get my current lender to drop my rate?
Not really — they’re paid when a loan moves, so repricing with your existing lender isn’t something they can do for you or get paid for. That phone call is yours to make, it’s free, and it works more often than people expect.
Will talking to a broker hurt my credit score?
A conversation won’t. Submitting applications will: each formal application leaves an enquiry on your credit file, and several in a short period looks bad to a lender. One of the real arguments for a broker is that they aim at the lender most likely to say yes, rather than you applying at three banks and collecting three enquiries.
Does a broker handle car loans too?
Different trade, different brokers. Car and asset finance brokers work much the same way and are paid much the same way, but the panels and the accreditations are separate. The car loan sums are here.